Best Italian Restaurant in Scottsdale, Arizona | Your Ultimate Guide

Italian food has a way of bringing people together. Whether it’s the irresistible aroma of simmering tomato sauce or the rich taste of handmade pasta, it’s no surprise that Italian cuisine is a favorite all around the world. If you’re anything like me, you’ve probably scoured the web searching for the best Italian restaurant in Scottsdale, Arizona, a place that delivers a perfect combination of authentic flavors, inviting ambiance, and stellar service. Luckily, Scottsdale is home to some fantastic Italian restaurants that never disappoint.

While Scottsdale might be famous for its luxury resorts and desert landscapes, its culinary scene is equally impressive, and Italian food plays a leading role. From cozy trattorias to high-end dining spots, there’s something for every palate when it comes to finding the best Italian eats.

Why Scottsdale Is an Italian Food Haven

Scottsdale is an amazing city with a culinary reputation that extends beyond the Southwest. Sure, there are great restaurants serving all kinds of cuisine here, but when it comes to Italian food, the city really stands out. There’s a strong presence of chefs with deep Italian roots, ensuring that authentic flavors shine through, while the laid-back Scottsdale vibe makes dining even more enjoyable.

Italian food holds a special place in our hearts because it’s all about family, love, and simple, fresh ingredients. And the beauty of Scottsdale is that it offers Italian dining experiences for every occasion, whether you’re looking for a casual pizza night or an upscale evening out. It’s no wonder Italian food is one of the most popular cuisines in the area.

What Makes an Italian Restaurant the Best?

Not every Italian restaurant can claim the title of “best.” But what exactly sets the best apart from the rest? Let’s take a look at the key elements that make a great Italian restaurant:

• Fresh Ingredients: Quality ingredients are non-negotiable. The best Italian restaurants use fresh produce, top-quality meats, and traditional Italian staples like olive oil, basil, and ripe tomatoes. You’ll taste the difference in every bite.
• Handmade Pasta: There’s nothing quite like handmade pasta. The texture, the flavor, it’s worlds apart from the store-bought stuff. If an Italian restaurant makes its pasta in-house, you can be sure they’re serious about authenticity.
• Warm Ambiance: Dining in an Italian restaurant is as much about the atmosphere as it is about the food. The best places make you feel like you’ve stepped into a cozy, family-run eatery in Italy. Expect welcoming staff, rustic décor, and maybe even an open kitchen where you can watch the chefs at work.
• An Amazing Wine List: Italy is known for its wine, so a great Italian restaurant should have a stellar wine selection to match its food. A well-curated wine list can take your dining experience to the next level.

With these key elements in mind, let’s dive into some of the best Italian restaurants in Scottsdale, Arizona.

Top Italian Restaurants in Scottsdale, Arizona

Olive & Ivy

If you’re looking for a spot that blends Mediterranean and Italian flavors, Olive & Ivy is a standout. Located in the heart of Scottsdale, this restaurant offers a stylish yet relaxed setting along the waterfront.

Their menu features a range of Italian-inspired dishes with a modern twist. I personally recommend the braised short rib rigatoni, it’s rich, hearty, and full of flavor. And if you have a sweet tooth, their olive oil cake is an absolute must-try. The extensive wine list is also a big draw, offering perfect pairings for every dish.

Don’t just read about it, join the fun! Explore upcoming events, restaurant deals, and nightlife hotspots on Laparizone.

Andreoli Italian Grocer

Stepping into Andreoli Italian Grocer is like being transported to Italy. Located on Via Linda, this family-owned gem doubles as both a restaurant and a grocery store, offering authentic Italian fare alongside imported Italian products. Chef Giovanni Scorzo brings his heritage to life with dishes inspired by his Calabrian roots.

Their handmade pastas and freshly baked pastries are just the beginning. Andreoli’s has an atmosphere that feels like home, and if you’re in the mood for a simple but perfect meal, their sandwich made with imported Italian meats is to die for. It’s a spot you can return to again and again, and each time feels like a little Italian getaway.

Marcellino Ristorante

If you’re in the mood for fine dining, Marcellino Ristorante is one of the best Italian restaurants in Scottsdale for an upscale experience. Chef Marcellino Verzino and his wife Sima run this beautiful restaurant with passion, and it shows in every detail, from the hand-made pastas to the intimate dining atmosphere.

The gnocchi alla sorrentina and fettuccine alla Bolognese are personal favorites. The dishes are made with precision and care, offering you a truly authentic Italian experience. Marcellino Ristorante also boasts an impressive wine list, ensuring your dinner is complemented by the perfect glass of vino.

Why Handmade Pasta is Worth the Hype

One of the things that makes Italian food so beloved is the dedication to quality, and nothing exemplifies that more than handmade pasta. There’s a reason why pasta made from scratch is a game-changer. It’s softer, more flavorful, and holds onto sauces better than any dried pasta could.

Take a restaurant like Fat Ox, for example. This Scottsdale favorite specializes in classic Italian recipes with a modern twist, but the real star of the show is their fresh, handmade pasta. Whether it’s the silky strands of their tagliatelle or the perfect little pillows of their tortellini, each bite is an experience.

Italian Food is More Than Just Pasta: Let’s Talk Pizza

When thinking of Italian food, we can’t forget about pizza. And Scottsdale has no shortage of incredible pizzerias that craft some of the best wood-fired pizzas outside of Italy.

Pomo Pizzeria

One of the most authentic pizza places in Scottsdale is Pomo Pizzeria. They follow the strict rules of the Associazione Verace Pizza Napoletana, ensuring their pizzas are made in the true Neapolitan style. The dough is soft and chewy with just the right amount of char from the wood-fired oven, and the toppings are simple but flavorful.

Their Margherita pizza is a classic, but if you want something more adventurous, try the tartufo pizza. It’s topped with earthy truffle oil and mushrooms, an indulgence worth every bite.

Dining in Scottsdale: An Experience, Not Just a Meal

What makes Italian dining special isn’t just the food. It’s the experience of sitting down for a meal, taking your time, savoring every bite, and enjoying the company of those around you. The best Italian restaurants in Scottsdale embrace this philosophy. They encourage you to slow down, enjoy the moment, and really appreciate the food and the atmosphere.

Whether you’re having a quiet date night or a lively family dinner, Italian restaurants in Scottsdale make it feel like a special occasion every time. They’ve perfected the art of turning a simple meal into an unforgettable experience.

Perfect Spots for Celebrating

Looking for a spot to celebrate a big moment? Scottsdale’s Italian restaurants offer plenty of options for those special occasions. Here’s one of my top picks:

Franco’s Italian Caffe

If you’re celebrating something special, Franco’s Italian Caffe in Old Town Scottsdale is the place to be. The atmosphere is intimate and charming, and the menu is full of Italian classics that are expertly prepared. Their veal piccata and linguine with clams are standouts, but you really can’t go wrong with anything on the menu. It’s the perfect spot for a romantic dinner or a milestone celebration.

FAQs

What is the best Italian restaurant in Scottsdale, Arizona?
The best Italian restaurants in Scottsdale include Marcellino Ristorante, Olive & Ivy, and Andreoli Italian Grocer, each offering their own take on traditional Italian cuisine.

Do any Italian restaurants in Scottsdale offer gluten-free options?
Yes, many Italian restaurants, such as Fat Ox and Olive & Ivy, offer gluten-free pasta and other menu items for those with dietary restrictions.

Are there family-friendly Italian restaurants in Scottsdale?
Absolutely. Places like Mamma Lucy and DeFalco’s Italian Deli are perfect for families, offering hearty, home-style Italian dishes in a welcoming environment.

Do Scottsdale Italian restaurants serve wine?
Yes, most Italian restaurants in Scottsdale have well-curated wine lists that feature Italian and local wines, with selections to pair perfectly with their menu offerings.

What’s the best pizza place in Scottsdale?
For authentic Neapolitan pizza, Pomo Pizzeria is a top pick. Their wood-fired pizzas follow traditional Italian methods, making them a favorite for pizza lovers.

Is handmade pasta common in Scottsdale’s Italian restaurants?
Many top Italian restaurants, like Marcellino Ristorante and Andreoli Italian Grocer, make their pasta from scratch daily, ensuring the freshest and most authentic dining experience.

Final Thoughts

When it comes to finding the best Italian restaurant in Scottsdale, Arizona, the choices are incredible. From the authentic, family-run Andreoli Italian Grocer to the upscale dining experience at Marcellino Ristorante, there’s a place for every taste and occasion. If you’re ever in the mood for a memorable Italian meal, Scottsdale is the place to be.